Tech reporters (including me) typically advise purchasing a modem for web service instead of leasing one from your supplier. It’s fast guidance that readers will keep in mind and, for the most part, it exercises. Take PCWorld’s own regional rates as an example– for the a lot of standard strategy, leasing a combination modem-router entrance from Comcast is $15 monthly or $180 annually. If you purchase a suitable modem and standard router for $100 overall, you’ll conserve cash.
But often leasing can still exercise in your favor. Case in point: Right now in San Francisco, Comcast is providing complimentary entrance leasings on choose prepare for the very first 2 years. If you prepare to move, hop to another provider for a much better cost, or otherwise require versatility, picking to lease can conserve you money and headache.
So how do you select your finest course forward? Here’s the ultra fast guide:
- Buy if you:
- Can’t alter companies and will stay on strategies suitable with the modem’s speed constraints
- Will just alter service providers that have overlap in suitable devices; likewise, you will stay on strategies suitable with the modem’s speed constraints
- Will remain on a strategy enough time to a minimum of break even relative to leasing a modem and do not mind if you do not draw out extra worth beyond that
- Hate providing your web service company any additional factor to slip up on your month-to-month costs
- Rent if you:
- Will alter web service providers prior to recovering cost on a modem purchase
- Will get the rental charge waived and will alter service providers (or purchase your own modem) prior to the advertising duration ends
- Hate handling technical problems all by yourself
- Need access to advantages (like no information caps) connected to utilize of the web company’s equipment
- Don’t have numerous linked gadgets (some companies top the variety of active gadgets on lower-priced strategies << cough>> Comcast<)
- Learn that your web service company needs it (sorry, that draws)
Of course, these situations do not deal with the subtleties of your particular choices and circumstance. For optimum optimization, you’ll need to ask yourself the 5 following concerns and crunch some numbers.
What’s the rate of the leasing?
Obviously, leasing a modem for no charge has a various effect than if it’s $6, $10, or $15 monthly. The month-to-month rate impacts the length of time it requires to recover cost on a modem purchase and if that time duration makes good sense for your scenario.
People who currently own modems can usually neglect this concern, other than when the rental rate is totally free. State you have an older DOCSIS 3.0 modem (or entrance), however Comcast is providing complimentary usage of a DOCSIS 3.1 entrance. Comcast’s equipment will work with gigabit strategies, however your gadget will not. For such high-speed strategies, the simple course is to utilize that entrance for the year or 2 (or nevertheless long that its rental cost is complimentary.) The ISP’s gadget might provide quicker Wi-Fi speeds than your existing router or entrance, depending on its age.
But if you’re registering for a strategy under 400 Mbps for download speeds and it were to cost even a penny-per-month to lease Comcast’s entrance? Your acquired DOCSIS 3.0 modem is going to be more affordable.
What functions are provided by your leasing alternative( s)?
Usually, leasing a modem implies you get a gadget that fulfills the most present specifications. Frequently your supplier will regularly update the modem with a more recent variation, too.
But the most recent bells and whistles do not matter much if you’re stuck to absolutely nothing however 50 Mbps download speeds at your area. Unless the leasing comes out more affordable than purchasing, you can purchase the least expensive suitable modem and stop, particularly if you currently own a router. You’ll have to be your own tech assistance.
What equipment do you currently own?
Speaking of your getting your own devices– more’s at play than simply the modem itself. As a wrap-up, you require a modem to equate the signal entering into your house so that your regional devices (PC, phone, and so on) can utilize it. A router makes it possible to share that connection amongst numerous gadgets all at once. And an entrance integrates both the functions of a modem and a router into one tool.
You might wind up requiring to purchase simply a modem, simply a router, or absolutely nothing at all. It depends upon the strategy you select, the variety of gadgets you wish to place on your network, and what your scenario might be like in the future.

Thomas Rau
Say you have no networking equipment of your own. Your agreement length will figure out the worth of purchasing vs. leasing. If you do lease, an entrance’s constraints might still need a router purchase. Some Internet companies (ahem, Comcast) limit lower-speed strategies to a handful of active gadgets. You’ll require your own devices to bypass that policy.
And, if you do have an existing modem or router (or both), a leasing might make good sense if your things isn’t suitable with the network or will not maximize the speeds you’re spending for.
What’s in your future?
Knowing your way of life can assist you minimize lost costs and irritation. : Do you move regularly in between places with a number of offered web suppliers? Purchasing a modem (or entrance) might be excessive of a dedication– you will not understand for sure which ISP you’ll wind up with next. Or the brand-new place might support much faster download speeds, making a formerly wise, economical purchase semi-obsolete.
On the other hand, you might be an individual who lives completely at one house with simply a single readily available web company. Leasing a modem might wind up much more pricey when sticking to the exact same supplier for the long run.
If you’re someplace in between– you do not move typically, however you can change suppliers quickly– then you’ll need to weigh other aspects, like existing devices that you currently own, how most likely you are to hop to a brand-new ISP or bargain over renewal rates, and more.
What’s your web supplier’s track record?
With some web companies, it might be more secure to give up a leasing. Billing mistakes are a very genuine phenomenon with ISPs and squandering minutes of your life arguing with customer care can be taxing. Even if you do not mind arguing with customer care, there might be other inflammations like Comcast’s above-mentioned limitations on active gadgets.
So, even if the mathematics exercises a bit more in favor of a leasing, purchasing might be the less expensive option. Time is its own kind of currency. Your psychological and psychological health are necessary, too.