In recent news, OpenAI has found itself entangled in a copyright lawsuit initiated by The New York Times. The lawsuit alleges that OpenAI’s ChatGPT AI tool reproduced Times’ articles verbatim. However, OpenAI vehemently denies these claims and has responded with a detailed blog post, asserting the case’s lack of merit and expressing hope for a potential partnership with the renowned media outlet.
OpenAI Claims The New York Times:
Addressing The New York Times’ Claims:
OpenAI argues that the Times “is not telling the full story.” It challenges the assertion that ChatGPT reproduced articles verbatim, claiming that the Times manipulated prompts to include regurgitated excerpts. OpenAI emphasizes that even when using such prompts, its models don’t typically behave the way the Times insinuates, suggesting possible manipulation or cherry-picking of examples.
Reducing Regurgitation and Unintentional Content Reproduction:
OpenAI acknowledges that it has actively worked to reduce regurgitation from its language models. The company points out that the Times refused to share examples of the alleged reproduction before filing the lawsuit. OpenAI admits that it took down a ChatGPT feature, called Browse, that unintentionally reproduced content, showcasing its commitment to addressing concerns and improving its technology.
Fair Use and Access to Human Knowledge:
OpenAI maintains its stance that AI models require access to the vast aggregate of human knowledge for learning and problem-solving. The company respects copyright ownership but argues that training AI models with internet data falls under fair use rules. It has offered opt-outs to training data inclusion and announced that website owners can block its web crawlers from accessing their data since August 2023.
Engagement with the UK House of Lords:
Open AI recently presented a similar argument to the UK House of Lords, emphasizing that AI systems like ChatGPT cannot be built without access to copyrighted content. The company asserts that AI tools need to incorporate copyrighted works to represent the full diversity and breadth of human intelligence and experience.
Hope for Constructive Partnership:
Despite the legal dispute, Open AI expresses optimism about continuing negotiations with The New York Times for a partnership, similar to those with Axel Springer and The Associated Press. The company respects the Times’ long history and believes in the potential for a constructive collaboration.
OpenAI‘s response to The New York Times’ lawsuit reflects its commitment to addressing concerns, improving its AI technology, and fostering partnerships with reputable media outlets. As the legal proceedings unfold, the tech company remains hopeful for a constructive relationship with The New York Times, emphasizing the importance of AI’s access to human knowledge for continued advancements in artificial intelligence.